Tell The Mods: How do you feel about off-topic content in this sub?

I'm creating this post because I want to get the communities' thoughts on off-topic posts in our sub.

A dilemma that's on my mind from time to time is when I see a post in our sub that's clearly offtopic or which has little to do with the Critical Drinker youtube channel or anything really directly covered by it, but which is otherwise positively received by the audience in the sub.

As a Tyrannical Reddit Mod (tm), my first instinct is to just remove posts that don't fit the purpose of the sub.

But at the same time, it feels like a lot of content that skirts by in the sub could be removed for the same reasons, and when I see something has say, 500 or 1000 net votes, I feel like it's a disservice to the sub taking it down.

In the end, a decision needs to be made about where the line is, and what we allow and what we don't allow, and we'd prefer that we have this line more clearly defined and in a format that we can share it with you, so that we all have the same expectations.

I don't know where a fair point for this is, and I want to get feedback from various people in the sub on your takes on it.

Feel free to gives your strongest arguments here for why you do or don't like seeing various things in the sub, and also feel free to bitch about how we mods handle various issues relating to them.

Also, as a fun thought experiment, please leave your best interpretation of what you believe the purpose of this subreddit is.