Since r/cursor mods deleted my post there I will post it here

But it’s not all flowers. Although on windsurf Im getting much higher quality code suggestions with R1, sometimes it won’t edit the file even though I told it 3x “hey, actually edit the file with your suggestion”, at that point I switched to sonnet and it did the edit. So it seems the current state is windsurf is better at generating good code with R1 but cursor is way more stable with their tab edit models. Hope the post won’t get deleted in this sub :)

But it’s not all flowers. Although on windsurf Im getting much higher quality code suggestions with R1, sometimes it won’t edit the file even though I told it 3x “hey, actually edit the file with your suggestion”, at that point I switched to sonnet and it did the edit. So it seems the current state is windsurf is better at generating good code with R1 but cursor is way more stable with their tab edit models. Hope the post won’t get deleted in this sub :)